Skip to main content

Coverage on Nutrient Neutrality

Posted by: , Posted on: - Categories: Natural England, Nature

There has been coverage in The Times today which covers comments from the Home Builders Federation, who claim that Natural England has blocked the building of over 160,000 homes due to nutrient neutrality rules, causing development levels to fall to their lowest level since the 1920’s.

Their reporting states that under the rules, developers in 74 councils have to demonstrate that new houses will not lead to more phosphates running into rivers but that critics argue the main causes of pollution are agricultural run off and the Victorian sewage system.

To clarify, work is underway with developers and local authorities to ensure that housebuilding can take place while protecting nature. In fact 242,700 homes were delivered in 2019/20 – a 32 year high.

In July, Defra and Natural England set out plans for a new nutrient mitigation scheme, and we have announced a series of measures to drive down nutrient pollution and help unlock construction of new homes across the country.

Defra and DLUHC will provide up to £30 million of funding over the next three years, which will be compensated through developers purchasing ‘nutrient credits’ to remove requirements in providing mitigation.

Local Planning Authorities can grant planning permission for developments which have secured the necessary nutrient credits.

All affected areas can continue to access practical support backed by £100,000 (per catchment) from the government and Natural England in meeting nutrient neutrality requirements.

The Government also launched the Local Nutrient Mitigation Fund Call for Evidence and Expression of Interest, seeking proposals from local authorities up to an indicative £10m threshold. Where high quality proposals are identified, we will provide funding to support clearer routes for housing developers to deliver ‘nutrient neutral’ sites, in line with their environmental obligations.

There will also be a legal duty on water companies in England to upgrade wastewater treatment works by 2030 in designated areas: Government sets out plan to reduce water pollution.

A Government spokesperson said:

We must protect the environment and improve water quality while delivering the housing this country needs.

We’re working closely with planning authorities affected by nutrient neutrality to provide more support and looking at what more we can do mitigate nutrient pollution. These schemes will deliver clearer routes for developers in tackling nutrient pollution and unlock construction of new sustainable homes.

Edel McGurk, Regional Operations Director at Natural England said:

The quality of our rivers and wetlands is a concern for people across England and we have been working with local authorities, developers, farmers and other landowners in a number of areas to make sure much needed housing can go ahead without causing damage to nature.

As a statutory consultee on planning applications to protect nature and wildlife we provide advice to local planning authorities. To assist developers we also provide pre-planning advice which can help ensure new developments provide suitable mitigation and avoid delays in the planning process – and we are committed to continuing to ensure that sustainable development and protecting nature go hand in hand.

Please see here for further information on our nutrient mitigation scheme.

Follow Defra on Twitter, and sign up for email alerts here.

Sharing and comments

Share this page


  1. Comment by Bethan Jones posted on

    It is plain to me that as long as someone is making money, the environment will not be a consideration. Agriculture is always blamed for everything, but we all need and want to eat, don't we? And how many of us are prepared to pay for the true cost of food production let alone the true cost of food production done to organic standards. We are all responsible for the pollution and destruction of this planet and our home environment. House builders put money into pockets of influential people regardless of how their actions affect our environment. This is more lip service.

  2. Comment by Luke Conway posted on

    It is commendable to see the implementation of nutrient neutrality rules as a way to protect the environment and promote sustainable development. Collaboration between Natural England, developers and local authorities appears to be a proactive step towards finding a balance between housing needs and nature conservation.